Transformative Engagements with Gender Relations in Agriculture and Water Governance
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53037/na.v5i1.50Keywords:
gender, transformative practice, critical pedagogy, agriculture, water, participatory action research, social learningAbstract
Despite frequent calls for transformative approaches for engaging in agrarian change and water governance, we observe little change in everyday development and research praxis. Empirical studies on transformative engagements with gender relations among smallscale or tenant farmers and water user groups are particularly rare. We explore transformative engagements through an approach based on critical pedagogy (Freire, 1996) and transformative practice (Leder, 2018). We examine opportunities to promote empathy and critical consciousness on gender norms, roles and relations in agriculture and resource management. We developed and piloted an innovative “Participatory Gender Training for Community Groups” as part of two internationally funded water security projects. The training consists of three activities and three discussions to reflect on gender roles in families, communities and agriculture, to discuss the gendered division of labour and changing gender relations over time and space, and to create empathy and resolve conflicts through a bargaining role play with switched genders. The approach was implemented in twelve villages across four districts in Nepal and India (Bihar, West Bengal). Our results show how the training methods can provide an open space to discuss local gender roles within households, agriculture and natural resource management. Discussing own gender norms promotes critical consciousness that gender norms are socially constructed and change with age, class, caste and material and structural constraints such as limited access to water and land. The activities stimulated enthusiasm and inspiration to reflect on possible change towards more equal labor division and empathy towards those with weaker bargaining power. Facilitators have the most important role in transformative engagements and need to be trained to reinterpret training principles in local contexts, and to apply facilitation skills to focus on transforming rather than reproducing gender norms. We argue that the gender training methods can initiate transformative practice with the gender-water-agriculture nexus by raising critical consciousness of farmers, community mobilisers, and project staff on possibilities of social change “in situ”.
References
Agarwal, B., 1997. ‘’Bargaining’’and gender relations: within and beyond the household. Feminist economics, 3, pp.1-51.
Agarwal, B., 2000. Conceptualising environmental collective action: why gender matters. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 24, pp.283-285.
Agarwal, B. 2001. Participatory exclusions, community forestry, and gender: an analysis for South Asia and a conceptual framework. World Development, 29, pp.1623-1648.
Ahlers, R. & Zwarteveen, M.Z., 2009. The water question in feminism: water control and gender inequities in a neo-liberal era. Gender, Place & Culture, 16, pp.409-426.
Bastakoti, R., Raut, M., Kumar, A. & Kanungoe, P.D., 2017. Assessing value chain opportunities for smallholder vegetable growers in Eastern Gangetic Plains, Kathmandu, Nepal, International Water Mangement Institute.
Bijman, J., Iliopoulos, C., Poppe, K.J., Gijselinckx, C., Hagedorn, K., Hanish, M., Hendrikse, G.W., Kühl, R., Ollila, P. & Pyykkönen, P., 2012. Support for farmers’ co-operatives. Final report.
Bunch, R., 1995. Two ears of corn: a guide to people-centered agricultural improvement.
Chambers, R., 1994. The origins and practice of participatory rural appraisal. World Development, 22, pp.953-969.
Cleaver, F. & Hamada, K., 2010. ‘Good’ water governance and gender equity: a troubled relationship. Gender & Development, 18, pp.27-41.
Cundill, G. & Rodela, R., 2012. A review of assertions about the processes and outcomes of social learning in natural resource management. J Environ Manage, 113, pp.7-14.
Dewey, J., 1916. Democracy and education, New York, The Macmillan Company.
Dorward, A., Poole, N., Morrison, J., Kydd, J. & Urey, I., 2003. Markets, institutions and technology: missing links in livelihoods analysis. Development policy review, 21, pp.319- 332.
Doss, C., 2013. Intrahousehold bargaining and resource allocation in developing countries. The World Bank Research Observer, 28, pp.52-78.
Elias, M., Jalonen, R., Fernandez, M. and Grosse, A., 2016. A gender-responsive participatory research for social learning and sustainable forest management. Forests, Trees and Livelihoods, 26, pp.1-12.
Farnworth, C.R. Gender-aware value chain development. UN Women in cooperation with FAO, IFAD and WFP, Expert Group Meeting. Enabling rural women’s economic empowerment: institutions, opportunities and participation, 2011. pp.20-23.
Freire, P., 1996. Pedagogy of the oppressed, London, Penguin Books Ltd.
Gurung, D. & Bisht, S., 2014. Women’s empowerment at the frontline of adaptation. Emerging issues, adaptive practices, and priorities in Nepal, Kathmandu, ICIMOD.
Harris, L., 2008. Water rich, resource poor: intersections of gender, poverty, and vulnerability in newly irrigated areas of Southeastern Turkey. World Development, 36, pp.2643-2662.
Hegde, N., Elias, M., Lamers, H.A.H. & Hegde, M., 2016. Engaging local communities in social learning for inclusive management of native fruit trees in the Central Western Ghats, India. Forests, Trees and Livelihoods, 26, pp.65-83.
Hoyt, C.L. & Murphy, S.E., 2016. Managing to clear the air: stereotype threat, women, and leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 27(3), pp.387-399.
Leder, S., 2018. Transformative pedagogic practice: education for sustainable development in Indian geography education on water conflicts., Singapore, Springer.
Leder, S., Clement, F. & Karki, E., 2017. Reframing women’s empowerment in water security programmes in western Nepal. Gender & Development, 25, pp.235-251.
Leder, S., Das, D., Reckers, A. & Karki, E., 2016. Participatory gender training for community groups. A manual for critical discussions on gender norms, roles and relations, Colombo, Sri Lanka, CGIAR Research Program on Water, Land and Ecosystems (WLE).
Leder, S., Sugden, F., Raut, M., Ray, D. & Saikia, P., 2019. Ambivalences of collective farming: feminist political ecologies from the Eastern Gangetic Plains. International Journal of the Commons, 13.
Locke, C. & Okali, C., 1999. Analysing changing gender relations: methodological challenges for gender planning. Development in Practice, 9, pp.274-286.
Martin, R., 1992. Bargaining power. Oxford, UK, Oxford University Press, p.210.
Mayring, P., 2002. Qualitative content analysis - research instrument or mode of interpretation? In: M. Kiegelmann, ed. The Role of the Researcher in Qualitative Psychology. Tübingen: Verlag Ingeborg Huber..
Meinzen-Dick, R. & Zwarteveen, M., 1998. Gendered participation in water management: issues and illustrations from water users’ associations in South Asia. Agriculture and Human Values, 15, pp.337-345.
Morales, M.C. & Harris, L.M., 2014. Using subjectivity and emotion to reconsider participatory natural resource management. World Development, 64, pp.703-712.
Mosse, D., 1994. Gender and knowledge: theoretical reflections on participatory rural appraisal. Economic and Political Weekly, 30, pp.569-571+573-578.
Mosse, D., 2004. Is good policy unimplementable? Reflections on the ethnography of aid policy and practice. Development and Change, 35, pp.639-671.
Nightingale, A.J., Eriksen, S., Taylor, M., Forsyth, T., Pelling, M., Newsham, A., Boyd, E., Brown, K., Harvey, B., Jones, L. and Bezner Kerr, R., 2019. Beyond Technical Fixes: climate solutions and the great derangement. Climate and Development, pp.1-10.
Panta, S.K. & Resurrección, B.P., 2017. Gender and caste relations amidst a changing political situation in Nepal: insights from a farmer-managed irrigation system. Gender, Technology and Development, 18, pp.219-247.
Rodela, R., 2013. The social learning discourse: trends, themes and interdisciplinary influences in current research. Environmental Science & Policy, 25, pp.157-166.
Shrestha, G. & Clement, F., 2019. Unravelling gendered practices in the public water sector in Nepal. Water Policy, 21, pp.1017-1033.
Sugden, F., Maskey, N., Clement, F., Ramesh, V., Philip, A. & Rai, A., 2014. Agrarian stress and climate change in the Eastern Gangetic Plains: gendered vulnerability in a stratified social formation. Global Environmental Change, 29, pp.258–269.
Sultana, F., 2011. Suffering for water, suffering from water: emotional geographies of resource access, control and conflict. Geoforum, 42, pp.163-172.
Sultana, F., 2019. Decolonizing development education and the pursuit of social justice. Human Geography.
Tremblay, C. & Harris, L., 2018. Critical video engagements: empathy, subjectivity and changing narratives of water resources through participatory video. Geoforum, 90, pp.174-182.
Udas, P.B. & Zwarteveen, M.Z., 2010. Can water professionals meet gender goals? A case study of the Department of Irrigation in Nepal. Gender & Development, 18, pp.87-98.
Vester, F., 2002. Unsere Welt - ein vernetztes System, München, Deutscher Taschenbuchverlag.
Zwarteveen, M. & Meinzen-Dick, R., 2001. Gender and property rights in the commons: examples of water rights in South Asia. Agriculture and Human Values, 18, pp.11-25.
Zwarteveen, M. & Neupane, N., 1996. Free-riders or victims: women’s nonparticipation in irrigation management in Nepal’s Chhattis Mauja irrigation scheme. Colombo, International Water Management Institute.