The Consensual Politics of Development: A Case Study of Hydropower Development in the Eastern Himalayan Region of India
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53037/na.v5i1.9Keywords:
Darjeeling, HydropowerAbstract
Criticism and contestation of large dam projects have a long, strong history in India. In this paper, we analyze diverse civil-society responses to large dam projects in the Eastern Himalaya region of India, which has in the past decades been presented as a clean, green, climate-mitigating way of generating energy, but critiqued for its adverse impacts more recently. We draw our findings primarily based on interviews with NGOs involved in environmental and/or water issues in Darjeeling, interviews with those involved in a local people’s movement ‘Affected Citizens of Teesta’, and participatory research over the course of three years between 2015 and 2018. Our findings show how doing development for the state, the market and/or donor organizations compromises the ability of NGOs in the Darjeeling region to hold these actors accountable for social and environmental excesses. In the same region, dam projects in North Sikkim led to a local people’s movement, where expressions of indigeneity, identity and place were used to critique and contest the State’s agenda of development, in ways that were symptomatically different to NGOs tied down by relations of developmental bureaucracy. Our findings reveal how the incursion of State authority, presence and power in civil-society undermines the civil society mandate of transformative social change, and additionally, how the geographical, political, institutional and identity-based divides that fragment diverse civil-society institutions and actors make it challenging to counter the increasingly consensual politics of environmental governance.
References
Ahlers, R., Budds, J., Joshi, D., Merme, V. & Zwarteveen, M., 2015. Framing hydropower as green energy: assessing drivers, risks and tensions in the Eastern Himalayas. Earth System Dynamics, 6(1), pp.195-204.
Arora, V., 2006. Roots and the route of secularism in Sikkim. Economic and Political Weekly, 41(38), pp.4063-4071.
Banks, N., Hulme, D. & Edwards, M., 2015. NGOs, States, and donors revisited: still too close for Comfort? World Development, 66, pp.707-718.
Berglund, H., 2009. Civil society in India: democratic space or the extension of elite domination. Working Paper, Stockholm, Stockholm University.
Brechin, S.R., 2016. Climate change mitigation and the collective action problem: exploring country differences in greenhouse gas contributions. Sociological Forum, 31 (S1), pp.846- 861.
Bryant, R.L., 2002. Non-governmental organizations and governmentality: consuming biodiversity and indigenous people in the Philippines. Political Studies, 50, pp.268-292.
Chattarjee, B., 1979. Geotechnical problems in planning and execution of hydro-electric projects in Darjeeling, India, Bulletin of the International Association of Engineering Geology, 20(1), pp.73-77.
Chatterjee, P., 2004. The politics of the governed: reflections on popular politics in most of the world. Columbia University Press.
Cohen, L., Manion, L. & Morrison, K., 2011. Research methods in education. London: Routledge.
Cox, R.W., 1999. Civil society at the turn of the millennium: prospects for an alternative world order. Review of International Studies, 25(1), pp.3-28.
Dharmadhikary, S., 2008. Mountains of concrete: Dam building in the Himalayas, Working Papers id:1815.
Duflo, E. and Pande R., 2007. Dams. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122(2), pp.601-646.
Ferguson, J., 1994. The anti-politics machine: development, depoliticization, and bureaucratic power in Lesotho. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
FICCI & PwC, 2014. Hydropower in India: Key enablers for a better tomorrow.
Foning, A. R., 1987. Lepcha, My Vanishing Tribe. New Delhi: Sterling Publishers.
Foucault, M., 1979. Governmentality. Ideol. Conscious, 6, pp.5-21.
Gergan, M., 2014. Precarity and possibility: on being young and Indigenous in Sikkim, India. Himalaya, The Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies, 34(2), pp.67-80.
Goldman, M., 2001. Constructing an environmental state: eco-governmentality and other transnational practices of a ‘green’ World Bank. Social Problems, 48(4), pp.499-523.
Gough, C. and Shackely, S., 2001. The respectable politics of climate change: the epistemic communities and NGOS. International Affairs, 77(2), pp.329-346.
Goyal, P., 2017. How India became power surplus country in three years: Piyush Goyal lists out achievements, Financial Express, June 12, 2017. [online]. Available at: .
Gramsci, A., 1971. Selections from the prison notebooks of Antonio Gramsci. New York, International Publishers.
Grumbine, R.E. and Xu, J., 2011. Mekong hydropower development. Science, 332(6026), pp.178-179.
Hammett, D. and Jackson, L., 2017. Developing a ‘civil’ society in partial democracies: In/ civility and a critical public sphere in Uganda and Singapore. Political Geography.
Huber, A. and Joshi, D., 2015. Hydropower, anti-politics, and the opening of new political spaces in the Eastern Himalayas. World Development, 76, pp.13-25.
Joshi, D., 2015. Like water for justice. Geoforum, 61, pp.111-121. Lewis, D., 2002. Civil society in African contexts: reflections on the usefulness of a concept. Development and change, 33(4), pp.569-586.
Li, T.M., 2007. The will to improve governmentality, development, and the practice of politics. Duke University Press.
Little, K., 2010. From the villages to the cities: the battleground for Lepcha protests. Transforming Cultures Journal, 5(1), pp.84-111.
Matthews, N. and Motta, S., 2015. Chinese State-owned enterprise investment in Mekong hydropower: political and economic rivers and their implications across the water, energy, food nexus. Water, 7(11), pp.6269-6284.
Matthews, N. and Schmidt, J.J., 2014. False promises: the contours, contexts and contestation of good water governance in Lao PDR and Alberta, Canada. International Journal of Water Governance, 2, pp.1-20.
McDuie-Ra, D., 2008. Between national security and ethno-nationalism: the regional politics of development in Northeast India. Journal of South Asian Development, 3(2), pp.185-210.
McDuie-Ra, D., 2011. The dilemmas of pro-development actors: viewing State-ethnic minority relations and intra-ethnic dynamics through contentious development projects. Asian Ethnicity, 12(1), pp.77-100.
Mohan, G., 2002. The disappointments of civil society: the politics of NGO intervention in Northern Ghana. Political Geography, 21 (1), pp.125-154.
Mohan, G., 2007. Participatory development from epistemological reversals to active citizenship. Geography Compass, 1(4), pp.779-796.
Nayak, A.K., 2010. Big dams and protests in India: a study of Hirakud dam. Economic and Political Weekly, pp.69-73.
Omvedt, G., 1993. Reinventing revolution: new social movements and the socialist tradition in India. An East Gate Book. London: M. E. Sharpe.
Omvedt, G., 1994. Peasants, Dalits and women: democracy and India's new social movements. Journal of Contemporary Asia, 24(1), pp.35-48.
Pomeranz, K., 2009. The great Himalayan watershed: agrarian crisis, mega-dams and the environment. New Left Review, 58, pp.5-39.
Rahman, S., 2006. Development, democracy and the NGO sector theory and evidence from Bangladesh. Journal of Developing Societies, 22(4), pp.451-473.
Rose, N. and Miller, P., 1992. Political power beyond the State: the problematics of government. The British Journal of Sociology, 43(2), pp.173-205.
Rose, N., O’Malley, P. and Valverde, M., 2006. Governmentality. Annual Review Law Society Science, 2, pp.83-104.
Sarma, E.A.S., 2014. The intelligence bureau and its not very intelligent report on NGOs. Economic and Political Weekly, XLIX (26), pp.10-12.
Sending, J, Neumann, I.B., 2006. Governance to governmentality: analyzing NGOs, States and Power. International Studies Quarterly, 50, pp.651-672.
Swyngedouw, E., 2009. The antinomies of the post-political city: in search of a democratic politics of environmental production. International journal for Urban Regional Research, 33(3), pp.601 620.
Swyngedouw, E., 2011. Whose environment? The end of nature, climate change and the process of post-politicization. Ambiente & Sociedade, 14(2), pp.69-87.
Tamsang, L., 2008. Lepcha Folklore and Folk Songs. Kolkota, Sahitya Akademi.
Upadhyay, A. and Singh, R., 2015. Cheap power or clean energy? India’s $200 billion dilemma, Bloomberg Business, July 30, 2015. [online]. Available at: <http://www.bloomberg.com/ news/articles/2015-07-29/cheap-power-or-clean-energy-india-s-200-billion-dilemma>.
Wangchuk, P., 2007. Lepchas and their hydel protest. Bulletin of Tibetology, 43(12), pp.33-57. West, B.A., 2009. Encyclopedia of the peoples of Asia and Oceania. Facts on File. Yates, J.S., 2012. Uneven interventions and the scalar politics of governing livelihood adaption in rural Nepal. Global Environmental Change, 22(2), pp.537-546.